Adoption & Breeders

How to Find a Reputable Breeder

Puppy mills and online scams look legitimate now. Here's exactly how to tell the difference and find a breeder you can trust.

📖 8 min read

The single biggest mistake puppy buyers make is choosing convenience over diligence. Puppy mills have perfected the art of looking like legitimate breeders online — professional websites, glowing reviews, "health guarantees" that mean nothing. Knowing the difference could mean the difference between 12 years of joy and $10,000 in vet bills for a genetically compromised dog.

Red Flags — Walk Away Immediately

  • Multiple breeds always available — responsible breeders specialize in one (occasionally two) breeds
  • "Puppies always available" — legitimate breeders have planned litters with waitlists, not constant supply
  • Won't let you visit — if they refuse to show you where the puppy was raised, walk away
  • No health testing documentation — good breeders test parents for genetic conditions and can show you results
  • Selling on Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace — most quality breeders don't need to advertise this way
  • Pushing wire transfer or Zelle — scammers want untraceable transfers; legitimate breeders accept normal payment
  • Ready to go at 5–6 weeks — puppies should not leave before 8 weeks minimum
  • Can't name or show you the parents — you should always be able to meet at least the mother
⚠️ Scam Alert: A common scam involves beautiful puppy photos, a suspiciously low price, then a "shipping fee" that keeps growing. Never wire money for a puppy you haven't seen in person.

What a Reputable Breeder Looks Like

  • Specializes in one breed and knows it deeply — can discuss health issues, history, and temperament at length
  • Performs OFA (hip/elbow), cardiac, eye, and other breed-relevant health tests on both parents
  • Raises puppies inside the home (not in outdoor kennels) and handles them daily from birth
  • Asks you as many questions as you ask them — they care where puppies go
  • Has a written contract with a health guarantee and a return clause for the dog's entire life
  • Provides AKC or other registry documentation for purebred dogs

Questions to Ask a Breeder

  1. "Can I see the health testing results for both parents?"
    Look for OFA clearances for hips, elbows, and breed-specific conditions. Results are publicly searchable at ofa.org.
  2. "Can I visit and meet the puppy and its mother?"
    Always yes. Watch how the mother interacts — her temperament strongly predicts her puppies'.
  3. "What does your contract include?"
    Look for a 2-year health guarantee for genetic conditions and a return clause requiring them to take the dog back if needed.
  4. "How do you socialize your puppies?"
    Responsible breeders introduce puppies to sounds, surfaces, people, and gentle handling during the socialization window (3–8 weeks).
  5. "How many litters per year does your female have?"
    One or two per year is typical. More is a red flag.

Where to Search

  • AKC Marketplace (akc.org/marketplace) — breeders who register litters and agree to AKC policies
  • National breed clubs — each AKC breed has a parent club with a breeder referral list. Search "[breed name] club of America breeder referral."
  • Dog shows — serious show exhibitors are almost always involved in health-focused breeding
  • Vet referrals — ask your local vet if they know breeders they trust
  • Word of mouth — a recommendation from a friend who has a happy, healthy dog from a specific breeder is the most reliable signal

What to Expect

  • Application/interview — many breeders have an application asking about your home, lifestyle, and experience
  • Waitlist — popular breeds can have waitlists of 6–18 months
  • Deposit — $200–$500 holds your spot; this is normal and legitimate
  • Pick-up at 8–10 weeks — puppies should leave with records, first vaccines, and a bag of their current food
Key Takeaway: If getting a puppy feels too easy, that's a warning sign. A reputable breeder will make you work a little — because they care where their puppies end up. The extra effort is absolutely worth it for the dog you'll live with for the next 12+ years.